Research Critiques and PICOT Statement Final Draft

Research Critiques and PICOT Statement Final Draft

A research critique is important because it enables the identification of the strengths and weaknesses of an article. This guides a researcher to determine the relevance of the articles in the specific topic of study. This critique evaluates two qualitative and two quantitative research articles to evaluate different aspects of the studies. A summary of the studies will be provided and the relevance of the study to the nursing practice issue identified. Furthermore, this paper will describe the methods and the findings of each of the studies and discuss the ethical considerations upheld by the authors of the articles. Additionally, this paper will make a comparison of the findings of the authors and those of my PICOT question and propose an evidence-based practice change. The clinal problem is racial discrimination to access proper health care nutritional, and holistic healthcare services.

Need help with your assignment ? Contact us.

Nursing Practice Problem and PICOT Question

The clinical problem is racial discrimination in accessing proper health care. nutritional, and holistic healthcare services. My PICOT question: Among the ethnic minority population, do culturally appropriate care-based interventions versus traditional approaches reduce discrepancies to access to health care services after six months? The two articles will be used to answer the PICOT question.

P: Ethnic minority population

I: culturally appropriate care-based interventions

C: traditional approaches

O: reduce discrepancies in access to health care services

T: six months

Background of the Study

The authors of the qualitative articles are Diaz Rios & Chapman-Novakofski, (2018) and Patel et al. (2020). According to Diaz Rios & Chapman-Novakofski, (2018), the purpose of the article is to conduct extensive interviews with experience-laden community nutritional researchers in the United States of America and identify the barriers and enablers of recruitment of Latinos and Hispanics, and evaluate any beneficial practice that the group enjoys. group enjoys. The objective of the study is to identify factors that influence participation and evaluate strategies that facilitate access of Latinos and Hispanics to community nutrition research. The research question: What are the factors influencing the participation of Latinos/Hispanics in research from the perspective of community nutrition researchers? The clinical problem is racial discrimination to access proper health care nutritional and holistic healthcare services. This is significant to nursing practice because nursing personnel should be on the front line of championing equity in health care service provision.

According to Patel et al. (2020), the purpose of their study is to evaluate demographic variations in health insurance knowledge. The objective of the study was to determine the level of understanding of health insurance and the Affordable Care Act among ethnic minorities in the USA. The research question that can be formulated from the study is: what is the impact of a multi-ethnic population on the understanding of health care insurance and the Affordable Care Act? The nursing problem is discrimination against access to health care services by the racial minority. This is significant to nursing practice because nurses should be actively involved in minimizing discrimination by advocating for policies that ensure equitable access to health care services.

The quantitative articles are authored by Tong et al. (2020) and Mann-Jackson et al. (2018). According to Tong et al. (2020), the purpose of their study is to determine the factors

that hinder the interest and willingness to participate in telemedicine among Hispanics, Latinos, and African Americans. The objective of the study is to evaluate patients’ reasons for minimal participation in the clinical trial involving telehealth. The study questions that can be formulated: What are the reasons for the diminished participation of Black and Hispanic patients in the clinical trial involving telehealth? What are the reasons for diminished compliance with the study protocol in the ongoing clinical trial involving telehealth? The article identifies the enablers of not embracing telemedicine are identified. Nursing personnel should be actively involved in patient education on the importance of telemedicine and ensure that it is implemented.

According to Mann-Jackson et al. (2018), the purpose of their research article is to evaluate the experiences of Latino men concerning discrimination, violence, and their legal status as immigrants to access health care services. Two objectives can be formul